E. H. Carr : biography
Carr emphatically contended that history was a social science, not an art.Huges-Warrington, p. 28 Carr argued that history should be considered a social science because historians like scientists seek generalizations that helped to broaden the understanding of one’s subject.Carr, What Is History?, p. 62 Carr used the example of the word revolution, arguing that if the word did not have a specific meaning that it would make no sense for historians to write of revolutions, even though every revolution that occurred in history was in its own way unique.Carr, What Is History?, p. 63 Moreover, Carr claimed that historical generalisations were often related to lessons to be learned from other historical occurrences.Carr, What Is History?, pp. 66–67 Since in Carr’s view, lessons can be sought and learned in history, then history was more like a science than any art.Carr, What Is History?, p. 68 Though Carr conceded that historians can not predict exact events in the future, he argued that historical generalisations can supply information useful to understanding both the present and the future. Carr argued that since scientists are not purely neutral observers, but have a reciprocal relationship with the objects under their study just like historians, that this supported identifying history with the sciences rather than the arts.Carr, What Is History?, pp. 70–71 Likewise, Carr contended that history, like science, has no moral judgments, which in his opinion, supports the identification of history as a science.Carr, What Is History?, pp. 74–75
Carr was well known for his assertions in What Is History? in denying moral judgements in history.Huges-Warrington, p. 29 Carr argued that it was ahistorical for the historian to judge people in different times according to the moral values of his or her time. Carr argued that individuals should be judged only in terms of the values of their time and place, not by the values of the historian’s time and/or place. In Carr’s opinion, historians should not act as judges.Carr, What Is History?, pp. 76–77 Carr quoted Thomas Carlyle’s remark on the British reaction to the French Revolution: "Exaggeration abounds, execration, wailing and on the whole darkness"…", and complained that exactly the same could be said about too much of Western commentary and writing on the Russian Revolution.Carr, What Is History?, p. 64; Laqueur, p. 126 Likewise, Carr quoted Carlyle on the Reign of Terror as a way of confronting Western complaints about Soviet terror: "Horrible in lands that had known equal justice-not so unnatural in lands that had never known it". Thus, Carr argued that within the context of the Soviet Union, Stalin was a force for the good. In a 1979 essay, Carr argued about Stalin that "He revived and outdid the worst brutalities of the earlier Tsars; and his record excited revulsion in later generations of historians. Yet his achievement in borrowing from the West, in forcing on primitive Russia the material foundations of modern civilisation, and in giving Russia a place among the European powers, obliged them to concede, however reluctantly his title to greatness. Stalin was the most ruthless despot Russia had known since Peter, and also a great westerniser". Though Carr made it clear that he preferred that historians refrain from expressing moral opinions, he did argue that if the historian should find it necessary then such views should be best be restricted to institutions rather than individuals. Carr argued that such an approach was better because the focus on individuals served to provide a collective alibi for societies. Carr used as examples those in United Kingdom who blamed appeasement solely upon Neville Chamberlain, those Germans who argued that Nazi-era crimes were the work of Adolf Hitler alone or those in the United States who blamed McCarthyism exclusively upon Senator Joseph McCarthy.Carr, What Is History?, p. 78; Huges-Warrington, p. 29 In Carr’s opinion, historians should reject concepts like good and Evil when making judgements about events and people.Carr, What Is History?, p. 82 Instead, Carr preferred the terms progressive or reactionary as the terms for value judgements.Carr, What Is History?, p. 83 In Carr’s opinion, if a historical event such as the collectivisation of Soviet agriculture in the early 1930s led to the growth of the Soviet heavy industry and the achievement of the goals of the First Five Year Plan, then the collectivisation must be considered a progressive development in history, and hence all of the sufferings and millions of deaths caused by collectivisation, the "dekulakisation" campaign and the Holodomor were justified by the growth of Soviet heavy industry.Carr, What Is History?, pp. 80–81 Likewise, Carr argued that the suffering of Chinese workers in the treaty ports and in the mines of South Africa in the late 19th-early 20th centuries was terrible, but must be considered a progressive development as it helped to push China towards the Communist revolution.Carr, What Is History?, p. 81 Carr argued that China was much better off under the leadership of Mao Zedong than it was under the leadership of Chiang Kai-shek, and hence all of the developments that led to the fall of Chiang’s regime in 1949 and the rise to power of Mao must considered progressive. Finally, Carr argued that historians can be "objective" if they are capable of moving beyond their narrow view of the situation both in the past and in the present and write historical works that helped to contribute to progress of society.Huges-Warrington, p. 30


