E. H. Carr : biography
Likewise, Carr charged that historians are always influenced by the present when writing about the past. As an example, he used the changing viewpoints about the German past expressed by the German historian Friedrich Meinecke during the Imperial, Weimar, Nazi and post-war periods to support his contention.Carr, What Is History?, pp. 40–41 The British historian Hugh Trevor-Roper, one of Carr’s leading critics, summarised Carr’s argument as: "George Grote, the 19th-century historian of Greece, was an enlightened radical banker; therefore, his picture of Periclean Athens is merely an allegory of 19th century England as seen by an enlightened banker. Mommsen’s History of Rome is similarly dismissed as a product and illustration of pre-Bismarckian Germany. Sir Lewis Namier’s choice of subject and treatment of it simply show the predictable prejudices of a Polish conservative".Trevor-Roper, p. 70
In general, Carr held to a deterministic outlook in history.Huges-Warrington, p. 27 In Carr’s opinion, all that happens in the world had a cause, and events could not happened differently unless there was a different cause. In Carr’s example, if one’s friend Smith suddenly starts acting out of character one day, then it must be understood that there is a reason for the strange behaviour, and that if that reason did not exist, than Smith would be acting normally.Carr, What Is History?, p. 94; Huges-Warrington, p. 27 Carr criticised counter-factual history as a "parlour game" played by the "losers" in history.Carr, What Is History?, p. 97 Carr contended that those who engaged in counter-factual speculations about Russian history, such as if Count Pyotr Stolypin’s land reforms were given enough time, would the Russian Revolution have been prevented, were those who were uncomfortable about the Bolsheviks being the "winners" of Russian history and their opponents were not. Likewise, Carr asserted those who stress the importance of "accidents" as a central causal agent in history were the "losers" of history, who wished to play explain away their defeats as the workings of chance and fate.Carr, What Is History?, pp. 99–101 In the same way, Carr argued that historians must concern themselves with the "winners" of history.Carr, What Is History?, p. 126 In Carr’s example, it is those who score centuries in cricket matches who are recorded, not those who are dismissed for ducks, and in the same way, Carr maintained that a preoccupation with the "losers" would be the equivalent of someone only listing the losers of cricket games.Carr, What Is History?, pp. 126–127 Carr dismissed the free will arguments made by Sir Karl Popper and Sir Isaiah Berlin as Cold War propaganda meant to discredit communism.Carr, What Is History?, pp. 91–95; Huges-Warrington, p. 27 In a similar way, Carr took a hostile view of those historians who stress the workings of chance and contingency in the workings of history. In Carr’s view, such historians did not understand their craft very well, or were in some way identified with the "losers" of history.
In the same way, Carr argued that no individual is truly free of the social environment in which they live, but contended that within those limitations, there was room, albeit very narrow room for people to make decisions that have an impact on history.Huges-Warrington, pp. 26–27 Carr made a division between those who, like Vladimir Lenin and Oliver Cromwell, helped to shape the social forces that carried them to historical greatness and those who, like Otto von Bismarck and Napoleon, rode on the back of social forces over which they had little or no control.Carr, What Is History?, pp. 54–55 Though Carr was willing to grant individuals a role in history, he argued that those who focus exclusively on individuals in a Great man theory of history were doing a profound disservice to the past.Carr, What Is History?, p. 46 As an example, Carr complained of those historians who explained the Russian Revolution solely as the result of the "stupidity" of the Emperor Nicholas II (which Carr regarded as a factor but only of lesser importance) rather than the working of a great social forces.


