E. H. Carr : biography
The History of Soviet Russia volumes met with a mixed reception. The Encyclopaedia Britannia in 1970 described the History of Soviet Russia series as simply "magisterial".Encyclopædia Britannica Book of the Year 1970, Chicago; University of Chicago Press, 1970 p. 476 The British historian Chimen Abramsky praised Carr as the world’s foremost historian of the Soviet Union who displayed an astonishing knowledge of the subject.Abramsky, Chimen "Tribute to E.H. Carr" pp. vii–viii from Essays In Honour of E.H. Carr ed. C. Abramsky and Beryl Williams, London: Macmillan Press, 1974 In a 1960 review of Socialism in One Country, the Anglo-Austrian Marxist scholar Rudolf Schlesinger praised Carr for his comprehensive treatment of Soviet history, writing that no other historian had ever covered Soviet history in such detail.Schlesinger, Rudolf "The Turning Point" pp. 393–414 from Soviet Studies, Volume 11, Issue # 4, April 1960 pp. 393–394 The Canadian historian John Keep called the series "A towering scholarly monument; in its shadow the rest of us are but pygmies."Laqueur, pp. 234–235 Deutscher called A History of Soviet Russia "…a truly outstanding achievement".Deutscher, Isaac "Mr E.H. Carr as a Historian of the Bolshevik Régime" pp. 91–110 from Heretics and Renegades, Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill, 1969 p. 94 The left-wing British historian A. J. P. Taylor called A History of Soviet Russia the most fair and best series of books ever written on Soviet history. Taylor was later to call Carr "an Olympian among historians, a Goethe in range and spirit".Davies, "Edward Hallett Carr", p. 473 The American journalist Harrison Salisbury called Carr "one of the half dozen greatest specialists in Soviet affairs and in Soviet-German relations".Haslam, The Vices of Integrity, p. 177 The British academic Michael Cox praised the History of Soviet Russia series as "…an amazing construction: almost pyramid-like…in its architectural audacity"Cox, Michael "Introduction" pp. 1–20 from E.H. Carr A Critical Appraisal ed. Michael Cox, London: Pargrave, 2000 p. 3 The British historian John Barber argued that History of Soviet Russia series through a scrupulous and detailed survey of the evidence "transformed" the study of Soviet history in the West.Barber, John "Carr, Edward Hallett" pp. 191–192 from Great Historians of the Modern Age ed. Lucian Boia, New York: Greenwood Press, 1991 p. 192 The British historian Hugh Seton-Watson called Carr "an object of admiration and gratitude" for his work in Soviet studiesHaslam, The Vices of Integrity, p. xi The South African born British Marxist historian Hillel Ticktin praised Carr as an honest historian of the Soviet Union and accused all of his critics such as Norman Stone, Richard Pipes, and Leopold Labedz of being "Cold War" historians who betoken to McCarthyism criticized Carr for being "for being on the side of the people".Ticktin, Hillel "Carr, the Cold War, and the Soviet Union" pp. 145–161 from E.H. Carr A Critical Appraisal ed. Michael Cox, London: Palgrave, 2000 pp. 148–151 Ticktin went to label Carr’s critics "…an entirely unsavory collection, not unconnected with serving the needs of official British and American foreign policy" who were "…closely identified with a discredited right-wing politics…".Ticktin, Hillel "Carr, the Cold War, and the Soviet Union" pp. 145–161 from E.H. Carr A Critical Appraisal ed. Michael Cox, London: Palgrave, 2000 p. 151 Ticktin described historians such as Pipes and Labedz as being "…never intellectuals but bureaucrats of knowledge, if not worse".Ticktin, Hillel "Carr, the Cold War, and the Soviet Union" pp. 145–161 from E.H. Carr A Critical Appraisal ed. Michael Cox, London: Palgrave, 2000 p. 154 Ticktin called Carr an "icon of the Left" who sought to honestly portray Soviet history.Ticktin, Hillel "Carr, the Cold War, and the Soviet Union" pp. 145–161 from E.H. Carr A Critical Appraisal ed. Michael Cox, London: Palgrave, 2000 pp. 155–157 In 1983, four American historians, namely Geoff Eley, W. Rosenberg, Moshe Lewin and Ronald Suny in a joint article in the London Review of Books wrote of the "grandeur" of Carr’s work and his "extraordinary pioneering quality".Davies, R.W. "Edward Hallett Carr" pg. 503 The four went on to write:"In the scope of his work Carr went where no one had gone before and where only a few have really gone since. He mapped the territory of Soviet history in the 1920s and delivered an agenda of questions which will be pursued for the rest of the 20th century…Carr’s analysis is now an indispensable starting point for understanding the dynamics of Stalinism". One of Carr’s students, the British historian Jonathan Haslam, called Carr a victim of British "McCarthyism" who was unjustly punished for his willingness to defend and praise the Soviet Union.Haslam, "E.H. Carr’s Search for Meaning, 1892–1982" pp. 21–35 from E.H. Carr A Critical Appraisal ed. Michael Cox, London: Palgrave, 2000 p. 32 The British Marxist historian Eric Hobsbawm wrote that the "…History of Soviet Russia constitutes, with Joseph Needham’s Science and Civilisation in China, the most remarkable effort of single-handed historical scholarship undertaken in Britain within living memory". The American historian Peter Wiles called the History of Soviet Russia "one of the great historiographical enterprises of our day" and wrote of Carr’s "immensely impressive" work The American Marxist historian Arno J. Mayer wrote that "…the History of Soviet Russia…established E.H. Carr not only as the towering giant among Western specialists of recent Russian history, but certainly also as the leading British historian of his generation".Carr, The Twilight of the Comintern, back-jacket Most unusually for a book by a Western historian, A History of Soviet Russia met with warily favourable reviews by Soviet historians. Normally, any works by Western historians, no matter how favourable to Communism, met with hostile reviews in the Soviet Union, and there was even a brand of polemical literature by Soviet historians attacking so-called "bourgeois historians" under the xenophobic grounds that only Soviet historians were capable of understanding the Soviet past".Laqueur, pp. 200–204


