E. H. Carr : biography
The Polish Kremlinologist Leopold Labedz criticized Carr for taking the claims of the Soviet government too seriously.Laqueur, p. 235 Labedz wrote that:"He [Carr] tended to confine himself to the penumbra of official formulations and of ideological formulas which always concealed, rather than revealed, real Soviet life".Labedz, p. 108; Laqueur, p. 235 Labedz argued that what he regarded as Carr’s worship of kratos (power) led him to engage in an apologia for Stalin by ignoring facts that placed Stalin in an unfavourable light and by highlighting those facts that placed Stalin in a positive light.Labedz, p. 99 Labedz noted it only after 17 years after the first volume of the History of Soviet Russia series was published did Carr criticize Stalin in volume 8 of the series, albeit only once and in a veiled form.Labedz, p. 1092 Labedz went on to argue that Carr’s decision to end the History of Soviet Russia series at 1929 reflected not the lack of documentary material as Carr claimed, but rather an inability and unwillingness to confront the horrors of Stalin’s Soviet Union.Labedz, p. 107 Labedz drew an unflattering comparison between Carr and Edward GibbonLabedz, p. 110 Labedz argued that:"To compare Carr’s approach with Gibbon’s is to register the contrast between his moral indifference and Gibbon’s human concern, his blinkered pedantry and Gibbon’s sovereign achievement in the sifting and validation of evidence." Labedz was very critical of Carr’s handling of sources, arguing that Carr was too inclined to accept official Soviet documents at face value, and unwilling to admit to systematic falsification of the historical record under Stalin.Labedz, p. 103 Finally, Labedz took Carr to task over what Labedz regarded as his tendency to white-wash Soviet crimes "behind an abstract formula which often combines "progressive" stereotypes with the lexicon of Soviet terminology".Labedz, p. 95 The British historian Norman Stone argued that Carr was guilty of writing in a bland style meant to hide his pro-Soviet sympathies. Writing of a History of Soviet Russia in 1983, Stone commented that: "Much of the book concerns economics, a subject on which Carr was hardly an expert. The lack of definitive point in the book…makes it dull and unrevealing. Like Carr himself it peters out…Carr’s History is not a history of the Soviet Union, but effectively of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union. Even then, much of it is the kind of unreconstructed Stalinist version that could not now see the light of day in Russia itself…I am nearly tempted to exclaim that no more useless set of volumes has ever masqueraded as a classic. Carr’s real talent lay in mathematics…From the mathematical spirit he took a quality not so much of abstraction as of autism which was carried over into his historical work. The result is a trail of devastation." Stone later wrote about Carr in 2004 that: "Tocqueville says somewhere that if you approve of dictatorship for a people, it means you despise the people. Carr did-he said at the end of his life that all those dead peasants meant progress. As Orwell said, it’s all very well saying you can’t make an omelette without breaking some eggs, but where’s the omelette?"Stone, Norman "Turkey in the Russian Mirror" pages 86-100 from Russia War, Peace and Diplomacy edited by Ljubica and Mark Erickson, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 2004 page 313.
The American historian Walter Laqueur argued that the History of Soviet Russia volumes were a dubious historical source that for the most part excluded mention of the more unpleasant aspects of Soviet life, reflecting Carr’s pro-Soviet tendencies.Laqueur, pp. 235–236 Laqueur commented that Carr called Stalin a ruthless tyrant in his 1979 book The Russian Revolution, and noted that he almost totally refrained from expressing any criticism of Stalin in all 14 volumes of the History of Soviet Russia series.Laqueur, p. 234 Likewise, Laqueur contended that Carr excelled at irony, and that writing panegyrics to the Soviet Union was not his forte.Laqueur, p. 125 In Laqueur’s opinion, if Carr is to be remembered by future generations, it will be for books like Dostoyevsky, The Romantic Exiles and Bakunin, and his History of Soviet Russia will besmirch the fine reputation created by those books. A major source of criticism of a History of Soviet Russia was Carr’s decision to ignore the Russian Civil War under the grounds it was unimportant, and likewise to his devoting only a few lines to the Kronstadt mutiny of 1921 since Carr argued it only a minor event. Laqueur commented in his opinion that Carr’s ignoring the Russian Civil War while paying an inordinate amount of attention to such subjects as the relations between the Swedish Communist Party and the Soviet Communist Party and Soviet diplomatic relations with Outer Mongolia in the 1920s left the History of Soviet Russia very unbalanced.


