E. H. Carr

0
115

E. H. Carr : biography

June 28, 1892 – November 3, 1982

A latter day controversy concerning Carr surrounds the question of whether he was an anti-Semite.Haslam, "E.H. Carr’s Search for Meaning" pp. 21–35 from E.H. Carr A Critical Appraisal ed. Michael Cox, Palgrave: London, 2000 p. 27 Carr’s critics point to his being champion of two anti-Semitic dictators, Hitler and Stalin, in succession, his opposition to Israel, and to most of Carr’s opponents, such as Sir Geoffrey Elton, Leonard Schapiro, Sir Karl Popper, Bertram Wolfe, Richard Pipes, Adam Ulam, Leopold Labedz, Sir Isaiah Berlin, and Walter Laqueur, being Jewish. Carr’s defenders, such as Jonathan Haslam, have argued against the charge of anti-Semitism, noting that Carr had many Jewish friends (including such erstwhile intellectual sparring partners such as Berlin and Namier), that his last wife Betty Behrens was Jewish and that his support for Nazi Germany in the 1930s and the Soviet Union in the 1940s–50s was in spite rather than because of anti-Semitism in those states.

History of Soviet Russia

After the war, Carr was a fellow of Balliol College, Oxford, and then Trinity College, where he published most of his popular works—A History of Soviet Russia and What Is History? He remained at Trinity College until his death. He was a tutor in Politics at Balliol College, Oxford from 1953 to 1955 when he became a fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge. In the 1950s, Carr was well known as an outspoken admirer of the Soviet Union. Carr’s writings include his History of Soviet Russia (14 vol., 1950–78). During World War II, Carr was favourably impressed with what he regarded as the extraordinary heroic performance of the Soviet people, and towards the end of 1944 Carr decided to write a complete history of the Soviet Russia from 1917 comprising all aspects of social, political and economic history in order to explain how the Soviet Union withstood the challenge of the German invasion.Hughes-Warrington, pp. 24–25 The resulting work was his 14 volume History of Soviet Russia, which took the story up to 1929. Carr initially intended the series to begin in 1923 with a long chapter summarizing the state of the Soviet Union just before Lenin’s death.Davies, "Edward Hallett Carr", p. 493 Carr found that the idea of one chapter on the situation in the Soviet Union in the year 1923 "proved on examination almost ludicrously inadequate to the magnitude of Lenin’s achievement and of its influence on the future".

Carr’s friend and close associate, the British historian R.W. Davies, was to write that Carr belonged to the anti-Cold-War school of history, which regarded the Soviet Union as the major progressive force in the world, the United States as the world’s principal obstacle to the advancement of humanity, and the Cold War as a case of American aggression against the Soviet Union.Davies. R.W. "’Drop the Glass Industry’: Collaborating with E.H. Carr" pp. 56–70 from New Left Review, Issue # 145, May–June 1984 p. 59 In 1950, Carr wrote in the defence of the Soviet Union that: "No sensible person will be tempted to measure the Russia of Lenin, Trotsky and Stalin by any yardstick borrowed from the Britain of MacDonald, Baldwin or Churchill, or the America of Wilson, Hoover or Franklin Roosevelt." Using that cultural relativist argument, Carr criticized those Anglophone historians who, he felt, had unfairly judged the Soviet Union by the cultural norms of Britain and the United States. In 1960, Carr wrote that: "Much of what has been written in the English speaking countries during the last ten years about the Soviet Union…has been vitiated by this inability to achieve even the most elementary measure of imaginative understanding of what goes on in the mind of the other party…"Laqueur, p. 116

Carr began his magnum opus by arguing that the 1917 October Revolution was a "proletarian revolution" forced on the Bolsheviks.Conquest, Robert "Agit-Prof" pp. 32–38 from The New Republic, Volume 424, Issue # 4, November 1, 1999 p. 34 Carr argued that:"It was the masses who drove their hesitating and temporising leaders down the path of revolution." In Carr’s opinion, since the Bolsheviks had driven to power against their will by the Russian people in 1917, they were then faced with the question of what to do with it.