James Hanratty

0
38

James Hanratty : biography

4 October 1936 – 4 April 1962

The argument for contamination was dismissed as "fanciful" by the judges, who concluded that the "DNA evidence, standing alone, is certain proof of guilt". Hanratty’s family and their supporters have continued to contest this conclusion.

Peter Alphon died in January 2009 following a fall at his home. The following month Richard Ingrams, a close friend and colleague of Paul Foot, wrote a brief article about Alphon’s part in the case in The Independent. Ingrams said that Alphon, in conversations with Foot and others, had spoken obsessively about the case, frequently incriminating himself. Ingrams said that Foot continued until his own death to believe in Hanratty’s alibi, despite the DNA tests of 2002.Richard Ingrams, , The Independent, 7 February 2009.

Evidence

Prosecution evidence anomalies

  • In the first identification line up, Valerie Storie picked out with total certainty an innocent airman, instead of the police suspect Alphon.
  • In the second line up, in which Hanratty was included, Hanratty stood out as his hair was bright orange; the police were so concerned about this they considered acquiring skullcaps.
  • In this line up, Valerie Storie picked out Hanratty, although she admitted she only ever saw the face of her attacker for a second or two when it was illuminated by a passing car’s headlights while he raped her.
  • In her original statement, Valerie Storie states the man who abducted and raped her was in his 30s, whereas in her second statement she changed this to ‘mid 20s’. James Hanratty was 25 but Peter Alphon was 31.
  • John Skillet picked out Hanratty as the driver of the Morris Minor as it sped down Eastern Avenue, but his companion, Edward Blackall, who had a closer view of the man, did not.
  • James Trower identified Hanratty as driving the Morris as it turned into Redbridge Lane, but Trower’s companion was adamant that Trower couldn’t have seen him from where they were standing.
  • Another prosecution witness was Roy Langdale, who was serving time in prison with Hanratty, and claimed that Hanratty confessed to him, but two others Hanratty exercised with said he consistently denied any involvement.
  • Charlie France, Hanratty’s erstwhile friend, testified that Hanratty had once said to him that ‘the back seat of a bus was a good place to hide something’.

Defence response

  • No witnesses, with the exception of Valerie Storie, were able to place Hanratty in the vicinity of Dorney Reach.
  • Elsie Cobb, who lived near the cornfield at Dorney Reach, stated that around 14:30 on 21 August she saw a man passing her house whom she described as aged 27 to 30, 5 foot 6 with dark hair brushed back and a thin nose. Her neighbour Frederick Newell added that the man had a sallow complexion.
  • The gunman said "I’ve been in institutions since I was eight": Hanratty is unlikely to have used words like "institutions".
  • Mary Lanz, proprietor of the Old Station Inn, Taplow, where Gregsten and Storie had last been before driving to the cornfield, was later able to identify Alphon as having also been there.
  • Even if the Rhyl alibi is disregarded, Hanratty’s meeting with Olive Dinwoodie would make his presence in Dorney Reach by 9 p.m. extremely implausible.
  • On Thursday 24 August at 20:40 Hanratty sent a telegram from Lime Street, Liverpool, in which he purported to be in London.
  • Although the cartridge cases were found in the Hotel Vienna, no one ever adequately explained how they came to be there on the day before the murder.
  • Hanratty disposed of his suit jacket six weeks after the crime; Alphon disposed of his raincoat straight away.
  • Unlike the gunman’s description of himself, Hanratty had never lived in a house with a cellar (let alone been locked in one and given only bread and water), was not coming up for PD, had not served five years for housebreaking, and had already been in prison on the Isle of Wight.
  • Valerie Storie had said that Jim was obviously not the gunman’s real name despite what the gunman claimed.
  • Juliana Galves said she saw Alphon with a pair of black gloves on his suitcase during his stay in the Vienna.
  • Peter Alphon wrote to the Daily Express in 1962 saying he believed Hanratty was innocent and he supported a reprieve.
  • Alphon wrote to the Home Secretary in 1962 saying "I killed Gregsten".