Fiore dei Liberi : biography
Flos Duellatorum (Pisani Dossi Ms.)
The Pisani Dossi Ms., titled Flos Duellatorum, was believed to have been lost in World War II and only resurfaced in a private collection in Italy in 2005. Novati described this manuscript as an unbound collection of leaves, covered with a cardboard folder with a marbled paper cover.dei Liberi, Fiore; Rubboli, Marco; Cesari, Luca, Flos Duellatorum: Manuale di Arte del Combattimento del XV Secolo, Rome: Il Icherio Initiative Editoriali, ISBN 88-8474-023-1 (2002) The Pisani Dossi Ms. is the only manuscript in the series that includes a date, claiming to be completed on 10 February 1409 after six months of effort. It consists of 36 folia and possesses two different prologues, one in Renaissance Latin and one in Italian. The body of the text consists of four to six illustrations per page, each with only a brief couplet or quatrain to explain it. This manuscript is typically referred to as either the ‘Novati’ or ‘Pisani Dossi version’.
The Pisani Dossi Ms. was published in facsimile by Francesco Novati in 1902, including the only reproductions of a copy of the Flower of Battle that are clearly in the public domain. However, it is unclear how accurate this facsimile is as evidence suggests that Novati may have hired an artist to create a tracing of the original manuscript rather than reproducing it directly. This would have provided ample opportunity for errors to creep into the images, and might also account for the significant divergences from the artistic style of the Getty and the Morgan.
The known provenance of the Pisani Dossi Ms. is:
- Completed by Fiore de’i Liberi on 10 February 1409. Though it was dedicated to Niccolò III d’Este, there is no evidence that it ever passed into his library.
- before 1663 – belonged to Schier de’ Prevosti da Valbregaglia, passed into the library of the Sacchi da Bucinigo family (purchased before 1902, Carlo Alberto Pisani Dossi).
- before 1902–present – owned by the Pisani Dossi family.
The contents of the Pisani Dossi Ms. are as follows:
- Latin Prologue (f 1r)
- Italian Prologue (ff 1r-1v)
- (ff 2r-2v – blank pages)
- Abrazare stances (f 3r)
- Abrazare plays (ff 3v-4v)
- Bastoncello plays (f 4v)
- Daga intro (f 5r)
- Daga plays (ff 5r-11v)
- Four strikes of the sword (ff 11v-12r)
- Spada a un mano plays (ff 12r-13v)
- Lanza plays (ff 14v-15v)
- Longsword against spear/unarmed against spear (f 15r)
- The seven swords (f 16v)
- Spada a dui mani stances (ff 16r-18r)
- Spada a dui mani wide plays (ff 19v-20v)
- Spada a dui mani close plays (ff 21r-23v)
- Spada en arme stances (ff 24r-24v)
- Spada en arme plays (ff 24v-25v)
- Azza stances (f 26r)
- Azza plays (ff 26v-27r)
- (f 27v – blank page)
- Mounted combat plays (ff 28r-32v)
- Spear vs. cavalry (f 33r)
- Mounted combat play (f 33v)
- Sword vs. dagger plays (ff 34r-35r)
- Exotic poleaxes (f 35r)
- Closing (f 35v)
Florius de Arte Luctandi (Mss. Latin 11269)
The Mss. Latin 11269, titled Florius de Arte Luctandi in a 17th-century script, is currently in the holdings of the Bibliothèque nationale de France. Any preface it once possessed is missing from the current form of the manuscript; it consists of 44 folios with two pairings per page, and is the only copy of Fiore’s treatise whose illustrations are fully painted. Unlike Fiore’s other works, this manuscript is written entirely in Latin; its descriptions are cast in couplets and quatrains similar to the Pisani Dossi Ms. This manuscript is generally referred to as either the Florius or the Paris.
The known provenance of the Mss. Latin 11269 is:
- Written in the early 15th century, probably after the completion of Flos Duellatorum in 1409.
- C. 1635 – rebound by a master papermaker who worked at the Puy-moyen mill for Sieur Janssen.
- before 1712 – in the collection of Louis Phélypeaux, marquis de Phélypeaux. Donated by him to the Bibliothèque du Roi, where it was labeled Florius de Art Luctandi.
- 1712–present – held by the Bibliothèque du Roi/Bibliothèque Nationale de France.
The contents of the Mss. Latin 11269 are as follows:
- Title page (f 1r)
- Segno with 7 swords and animal virtues (f 1v)
- Mounted combat (ff 2r-5v)
- Spear vs. cavalry (ff 6r-6v)
- Lanza plays (ff 6v-7v)
- Plays of spear with dagger and two clubs with dagger (f 8r-8v)
- Azza plays (ff 8v-10r)
- Spada a un mano (ff 10r-12r)
- Spada a dui mani stances (ff 12v-13v)
- Spada a dui mani wide plays (ff 14r-15v)
- Spada en arme plays (ff 16r-17v)
- Spada en arme stances (f 18r)
- Spada en arme plays (ff 18r-18v)
- (f 19r – blank page)
- Spada en arme stances (f 19v)
- Sword vs. dagger plays (ff 20r-20v)
- Daga intro (f 21r)
- Daga plays (ff 21v-25v)
- Spada a dui mani wide play (ff 26r)
- Spada a dui mani close plays (ff 26r-30v)
- Daga plays (ff 31r-38r)
- Abrazare stances (f 38v)
- Abrazare plays (ff 39r-42v)
- Daga plays (ff 43r-44r)
- Closing (f 44r)
Codices LXXXIV and CX
The Codex LXXXIV (or Ms. 84) is mentioned in the 1436 and 1508 catalogs of the Biblioteca Estense in Ferrara, but disappeared some time in the sixteenth century. It consisted of 58 folios bound in leather with a clasp, with a white eagle and two helmets on the first page. The Codex CX (or Ms. 110) is also mentioned in the 1436 and 1508 catalogs of the Biblioteca Estense, but not in later inventories. It consisted of 15 small-format folios on unbound parchment, and was written in two columns.Novati, pp 29-30.
The contents and current whereabouts of these copies of the Flower of Battle are unknown. It is possible that these listings refer to two of the manuscripts listed above, though none possess the correct number of folios or match the physical descriptions.


