Fiore dei Liberi : biography
Despite the depth and complexity of his writings, Fiore dei Liberi does not seem to have been a very significant master in the development of Italian fencing. That field was instead dominated by the tradition of his near-contemporary, the Bolognese master Filippo di Bartolomeo Dardi. Even so, there are a number of later treatises which bear strong resemblance to his work, including the writings of Filippo Vadi of Pisa and Ludwig VI von Eyb of Hartenstein. This may be due to his direct influence, or it may instead indicate that the older tradition of Suvenus and Toblem survived and flourished outside of his direct line.
The Flower of Battle
Four illuminated manuscript copies of this treatise are currently known to exist, and there are records of at least two others whose current locations are unknown. The Ms. Ludwig XV 13 and the Pisani Dossi Ms. are both dedicated to Niccolò III d’Este and state that they were written at his request and according to his design. The Ms. M.383, on the other hand, lacks a dedication and claims to have been laid out according to his own intelligence while the Mss. Latin 11269 lost any dedication it might have had along with its prologue. Each of the extant copies of the Flower of Battle follows a distinct order, though both of these pairs contain strong similarities to each other in order of presentation.
The major sections of the work include: abrazare, unarmed plays (usually translated as wrestling but more literally grappling); daga, including both unarmed defenses against the dagger and plays of dagger against dagger; spada a un mano, the use of the longsword in one hand (also called "the sword without the buckler"); spada a dui mani, the use of the longsword in two hands; spada en arme, the use of the longsword in armor (primarily techniques from the halfsword); azza, plays of the poleaxe in armor; lancia, spear and staff plays; and mounted combat (including the spear, the longsword, and mounted grappling). Brief bridging sections serve to connect each of these, covering such topics as bastoncello, or plays of a small stick or baton against unarmed and dagger-wielding opponents; plays of longsword vs. dagger; plays of staff and dagger and of two clubs and a dagger; and the use of the chiavarina against a man on horseback.
The format of instruction is largely consistent across all of the copies of the treatise. Each section begins with a Master Remedy, a figure in a golden crown who demonstrates a counter technique against a basic attack. He is followed by various Scholars, figures wearing golden garters on their legs who demonstrate iterations and variations on this counter. After the Scholars there is a Master Contrario, a figure wearing both a crown and a garter, who demonstrates how to counter the Master Remedy’s technique (and those of the Scholars). Some sections feature multiple Masters Remedy or Masters Contrario, while some have only one. There are also many cases in which an image in one copy will only feature a scholar’s garter where the corresponding image in another copy also features a master’s crown. Depending on the instance, this may be intentional or may be an error in the art.
Fior di Battaglia (Ms. M.383)
The Ms. M.383, titled Fior di Battaglia, is in the holdings of the Morgan Library & Museum in New York City, NY. Novati described it as a small, thin, vellum folio, pen and ink with gold highlights, and illustrations of sword and lance combat on foot and horseback. Unlike the other surviving manuscripts, the swords and other weapons were enameled in silver, though it has since tarnished to a glossy black. This is the briefest copy of Fiore’s work currently known, with only 19 folios; it has a prologue in Italian and four illustrated figures per page in the main body. The figures are accompanied by text that is often identical to that of the Ms. Ludwig XV 13 (excepting differences in spelling), but at times includes additional explanation. The Ms. M.383 is almost certainly longer when it was first written; its text makes reference to sections on poleaxe, dagger, and grappling which are not present in the book’s current state. It also refers to a certain play of the sword in one hand which is likewise missing from that section. This manuscript is typically referred to as the ‘Pierpont Morgan version’ or simply the ‘Morgan’.


