El Greco : biography
Art historian Max Dvořák was the first scholar to connect El Greco's art with Mannerism and Antinaturalism.J.A. Lopera, El Greco: From Crete to Toledo, 20–21 Modern scholars characterize El Greco's theory as "typically Mannerist" and pinpoint its sources in the Neoplatonism of the Renaissance.J. Brown, El Greco and Toledo, 110* F. Marias, El Greco's Artistic Thought, 183–184 Jonathan Brown believes that El Greco endeavored to create a sophisticated form of art;J. Brown, El Greco and Toledo, 110 according to Nicholas Penny "once in Spain, El Greco was able to create a style of his own—one that disavowed most of the descriptive ambitions of painting".N. Penny,
In his mature works El Greco demonstrated a characteristic tendency to dramatize rather than to describe. The strong spiritual emotion transfers from painting directly to the audience. According to Pacheco, El Greco's perturbed, violent and at times seemingly careless-in-execution art was due to a studied effort to acquire a freedom of style. El Greco's preference for exceptionally tall and slender figures and elongated compositions, which served both his expressive purposes and aesthetic principles, led him to disregard the laws of nature and elongate his compositions to ever greater extents, particularly when they were destined for altarpieces.M. Lambraki-Plaka, El Greco, 57–59 The anatomy of the human body becomes even more otherworldly in El Greco's mature works; for The Virgin of the Immaculate Conception El Greco asked to lengthen the altarpiece itself by another "because in this way the form will be perfect and not reduced, which is the worst thing that can happen to a figure'". A significant innovation of El Greco's mature works is the interweaving between form and space; a reciprocal relationship is developed between the two which completely unifies the painting surface. This interweaving would re-emerge three centuries later in the works of Cézanne and Picasso.
Another characteristic of El Greco's mature style is the use of light. As Jonathan Brown notes, "each figure seems to carry its own light within or reflects the light that emanates from an unseen source".J. Brown, El Greco and Toledo, 136 Fernando Marias and Agustín Bustamante García, the scholars who transcribed El Greco's handwritten notes, connect the power that the painter gives to light with the ideas underlying Christian Neo-Platonism.Marias-Bustamante, , 52
Modern scholarly research emphasizes the importance of Toledo for the complete development of El Greco's mature style and stresses the painter's ability to adjust his style in accordance with his surroundings.N. Hadjinikolaou, Inequalities in the work of Theotocópoulos, 89–133 Harold Wethey asserts that "although Greek by descent and Italian by artistic preparation, the artist became so immersed in the religious environment of Spain that he became the most vital visual representative of Spanish mysticism". He believes that in El Greco's mature works "the devotional intensity of mood reflects the religious spirit of Roman Catholic Spain in the period of the Counter-Reformation".
El Greco also excelled as a portraitist, able not only to record a sitter's features but also to convey their character.The Metropolitan Museum of Art, His portraits are fewer in number than his religious paintings, but are of equally high quality. Wethey says that "by such simple means, the artist created a memorable characterization that places him in the highest rank as a portraitist, along with Titian and Rembrandt".
Suggested Byzantine affinities
[[View of Toledo (c. 1596–1600, oil on canvas, , Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York) is one of the two surviving landscapes of Toledo painted by El Greco.]]
Since the beginning of the 20th century, scholars have debated whether El Greco's style had Byzantine origins. Certain art historians had asserted that El Greco's roots were firmly in the Byzantine tradition, and that his most individual characteristics derive directly from the art of his ancestors,R. Byron, Greco: The Epilogue to Byzantine Culture, 160–174* A. Procopiou, El Greco and Cretan Painting, 74 while others had argued that Byzantine art could not be related to El Greco's later work.M.B Cossío, El Greco, 501–512
