Aaron Burr : biography
Burr is known as the father of modern political campaigning. He enlisted the help of members of Tammany Hall, a social club, to win the voting for selection of Electoral College delegates. He was then placed on the Democratic-Republican presidential ticket in the 1800 election with Jefferson. At the time, most states' legislatures chose the members of the U.S. Electoral College, and New York was crucial to Jefferson. Though Jefferson did win New York, he and Burr tied for the presidency with 73 electoral votes each.
It was well understood that the party intended that Jefferson should be president and Burr vice president, but the responsibility for the final choice belonged to the House of Representatives. The attempts of a powerful faction among the Federalists to secure the election of Burr failed, partly due to opposition by Alexander Hamilton.
As Thomas Baker asserts in his piece, "An Attack Well Directed," William P. Van Ness, now believed to be in cahoots with Aaron Burr, had a scheme that was explained in a letter from Edward Livingston, a Democratic-Republican Representative. Van Ness had a plan to swing the election in Burr’s favor by first having Livingston or another colleague vote for Burr on the first ballot, dead locking New York. On the second ballot, Livingston would swing three House republicans from the vulnerable states of New York, New Jersey, and Vermont to vote for Burr.Baker, p. 555–556 Livingston may have been planning on writing Burr’s name but his mind was changed on his way to Washington. This was likely due to the fact that there was a strong belief that some Federalists would vote for Jefferson to avoid a hung election.Baker, pp. 585–586 Despite the last minute renege of Livingston, Jefferson still lost the first ballot due to the scrambling of Burr supporters to keep Maryland voters on the side of the Federalists.Baker, p. 586 Even with the loss on the first ballot, there was little instability on the Democratic-Republican side of the ticket on the second ballot.Baker, p. 590 Ultimately, it took 36 ballots before James A. Bayard, a Delaware Federalist, and several of his Federalist colleagues submitted blank votes to decide the election in Jefferson's favor.
Mudslinging was highly used to (attempt to) exploit the candidates, specifically Burr, in a biased light. This resulted in the public going at each other's throats to defend the candidate that each thought was best to lead the country.Fleming, Duel, 205-209 While Van Ness and Burr had their own plans to turn the election in their favor, James Cheetham, a supporter of Clinton, had his own plan to discredit Burr. Cheetham released Van Ness’ letter.Baker, p. 569 Burr gave another opening for Cheetham and DeWitt Clinton to amplify accusations when he showed interest in certain Federalists. They accused Burr of, “tampering with New York’s electors; blathering about Jefferson buying off wavering Republicans to ensure his election; actively intriguing with Federalists to capture the chief magistracy in 1804”.Baker, pp. 570–571
Cheetham and Clintonians released a series of letters in American Citizen. These eight letters were meant to expose the supposed conspiracy of Burr, Van Ness, Ogden and Livingston. Many Republicans were persuaded by these letters and the arguments Burrites tried to defend themselves with led to more admissions.Baker, pp. 575–576 When it came to the 9th letter in this series, Livingston was the key to the details to take down Burr. Cheetham pushed for details from Livingston on interactions with Ogden and Van Ness.Baker, p. 577 Livingston would not give in and Cheetham sent him letters explaining his already expansive knowledge of the contents of the letter with Van Ness and threats such as, “We stand upon the best ground. We know Mr. Burr is guilty. You have in fact, and I may say in express term, committed his guilt to me”.Baker, p. 580
Livingston’s resistance of James Cheetham’s push for information on Van Ness’ original letter for that 9th letter in American Citizen was what saved Burr from exposure, at least temporarily.Baker, pp. 581–582 In reality, Burr dragged out the drama and uncertainty of the election of 1800 for the purpose of manipulating it to his will. Burr’s actions had results throughout the nation of general instability.Baker, p. 594
