Evelyn Waugh : biography
Reception
Of Waugh’s early books, Decline and Fall was hailed by Arnold Bennett in the Evening Standard as "an uncompromising and brilliantly malicious satire".Stannard, Vol. I p. 158 The critical reception of Vile Bodies two years later was even more enthusiastic, with Rebecca West predicting that Waugh was "destined to be the dazzling figure of his age". However, A Handful of Dust, later widely regarded as Waugh’s masterpiece, received a more muted welcome from critics, despite Waugh’s own high estimation of the work.Hastings, pp. 313–14 The book’s ending, with Tony Last condemned forever to read Dickens to his mad jungle captor, was thought by author and critic Henry Yorke to reduce an otherwise believable book to "phantasy". Cyril Connolly’s first reaction to the book was that Waugh’s powers were failing, an opinion he later revised.Stannard, Vol I pp. 375–77
In the latter 1930s Waugh’s inclination to Catholic and conservative polemics affected his standing with the general reading public. The Campion biography is said by David Wykes to be "so rigidly biased that it has no claims to make as history".Wykes, p. 112 The pro-fascist tone in parts of Waugh in Abyssinia offended readers and critics, and prevented its publication in America.Hastings, p. 345 There was general relief among critics when Scoop, in 1938, indicated a return to Waugh’s earlier comic style; critics had begun to think that his wit had been displaced by partisanship and propaganda.
Waugh maintained his reputation in 1942 with Put Out More Flags, which sold well, despite wartime restrictions on paper and printing.Stannard, Vol. II pp. 72–73 Its public reception, however, did not compare with that accorded to Brideshead Revisited three years later, on both sides of the Atlantic. Brideshead’s selection as the American Book of the Month swelled its US sales to an extent that dwarfed those in Britain, which was affected by paper shortages.Stannard, Vol. II p. 148 Despite the public’s enthusiasm, critical opinion was split. Brideshead’s Catholic standpoint offended some critics who had greeted Waugh’s earlier novels with warm praise. Its perceived snobbery and its deference to the aristocracy were attacked by, among others, Conor Cruise O’Brien who, in the Irish literary magazine The Bell, wrote of Waugh’s "almost mystical veneration" for the upper classes.Conor Cruise O’Brien in "The Pieties of Evelyn Waugh", reprinted in Stannard: Evelyn Waugh: The Critical Heritage, pp. 255–63. (O’Brien used the pen-name "Donat Donnelly").Patey, pp. 262–63 Fellow-writer Rose Macaulay believed that Waugh’s genius had been adversely affected by the intrusion of his right-wing partisan alter ego, and that he had lost his detachment: "In art so naturally ironic and detached as his, this is a serious loss".Carpenter (ed.), p. 288 Conversely, the book was praised by Yorke, Graham Greene, and in glowing terms by Harold Acton, who was particularly impressed by its evocation of 1920s Oxford.Hastings, p. 492 In 1959, at the request of publishers Chapman and Hall and in some deference to his critics, Waugh revised the book and wrote in a preface: "I have modified the grosser passages but not obliterated them because they are an essential part of the book".From Waugh’s preface to the revised edition, published by Chapman and Hall, 1960.
In "Fan Fare", Waugh forecasts that his future books will be unpopular because of their religious theme. On publication in 1950, Helena was received indifferently by the public and by critics, who disparaged the awkward mixing of 20th-century schoolgirl slang with otherwise reverential prose.Hastings, pp. 538–41 Otherwise, Waugh’s prediction proved unfounded; all the fiction remained in print and sales stayed healthy. During his successful 1957 lawsuit against the Daily Express, Waugh’s counsel produced figures showing total sales to that time of over four million books, two-thirds in Britain and the rest in America.Stannard, Vol. II pp. 382–85 Men at Arms, the first volume of his war trilogy, won the James Tait Black Memorial Prize in 1953;Patey, p. 309 initial critical comment was lukewarm, with Connolly likening Men at Arms to beer rather than champagne.Stannard, Vol. II p. 306 Connolly changed his view later, calling the completed trilogy "the finest novel to come out of the war".Stannard, Vol. II pp. 438–39 Of Waugh’s other major postwar works, the Knox biography was admired within Waugh’s close circle but criticised by others in the Church for its depiction of Knox as an unappreciated victim of the Catholic hierarchy.Patey, p. 343 The book did not sell well—"like warm cakes", according to Waugh.Amory (ed.), p. 571 Pinfold surprised the critics by its originality; its plainly autobiographical content, Hastings suggests, gave the public a fixed image of Waugh—"stout, splenetic, red-faced and reactionary, a figure from burlesque complete with cigar, bowler hat and loud checked suit."Hastings, p. 567


